Reverend Father Richard Collender 1919 - 1925

Reverend Father E. McAuliffe 1925 - 1926

Reverend Father Richard Collenderand Reverend Father E. McAuliffe 1926 - 1941

Right Reverend Monsignor Richard Collender 1941 - 1942

Venerable Archdeacon E. McAuliffe 1942 - 1946

Right Reverend Monsignor Richard Collender and Venerable Archdeacon E. McAuliffe 1946 - 1959

Reverend Father John B. Roche 1959 - 1963

Reverend Father John B. Roche assisted by Reverend Father Luigi Tosi 1963 - 1970